Best Rubber Hunting Boots | Reviews of the Top Rated (2019)

Last Updated: by Aiden Williams

best rubber hunting boots

Those of you who are regular visitors will know that I’m pretty hard on my gear. It’s not deliberate, but when you’re out in the wild, it’s easy to damage your gear. Normal wear and tear also play a huge role.

To cut a long story short, I had to get yet another pair of hunting boots. I chose a reasonably good pair. It didn’t have waterproofing, but I wasn’t going to be hunting in the rain, so why would that matter?

I learned why pretty fast. We were tracking a deer. It was a chilly day with plenty of dew on the ground. It wasn’t long before my boots and socks got saturated. Soon afterward, I was shivering. My feet were freezing, and all I wanted to do was get home and get warm.

Needless to say, it’s something I’ve never lived down. Anyway, the reason that I bring up this tale of woe is that it inspired me to search out the perfect pair of waterproof boots. I eventually ended up with the best rubber hunting boots.

My Top Pick

Hands down the best rubber hunting boots in 2019 are the Kamik Boots. Made from recycled materials and with innovative design features, these crush the competition.

The Best Rubber Hunting Boots Reviewed

LaCrosse Alphaburly Hunting Boot

LaCrosse is a brand known for quality construction and materials. These boots were designed for those who are going to have to spend some time in the water.

Key Features

  • Rubber outer
  • Inner core made of neoprene
  • 100-percent waterproof
  • Lug pattern on the sole
  • The distance from the shaft and arch is around 16 inches
  • Has scent-busting chemicals built-in
  • Flexible
  • Shank made of nylon
  • Inner lining made of moisture-wicking mesh

What I Like About This Product

Rubber boots don’t leave a scent that’s obvious to deer and other animals, so you don’t have to worry about using a scent masker as much. The internal scent-busting lining prevents the inside from smelling too funky over time.

These are warmer than the standard rubber boot because of the inner and outer shell. The moisture-wicking layer draws the sweat away from your skin and keeps your feet dry.

The nylon shank has some stretch, which helps the top fit better too.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

You’re going to feel the heat in these if it’s hot out. There’s no way for the heat build-up to dissipate. If you’re in the water, it won’t be that bad, but if you’re going to be making long trips with a lot of hiking, it might not be the best option.

Pros

  • Scent masking
  • Quality build and materials
  • Durable
  • Waterproof
  • Comfortable
  • Some insulation
  • Lined

Cons

  • Not as light as I’d like
  • No air circulation

All in all, they deliver reliable performance.

Overall Rating

4 ½ out of 5 Don’t let your next hunt become your Waterloo.

Check Price on Amazon

Bogs Classic Waterproof Boot

Waterproofing doesn’t get much better than this – Bogs delivers yet another winner.

Key Features

  • Rubber exterior
  • Interior bootie-style lining
  • Moisture-wicking
  • Imported
  • Thick rubber sole
  • Distance from arch to the shaft is around 12 inches
  • Contains odor-beating tech in the lining

What I Like About This Product

Here Bogs has chosen comfort over style. The design might seem a little dated, but it delivers comfort big time. Water is not going to get anywhere near your toes until you decide it should.

The bootie on the inside improves comfort because it helps it fit more snugly. The lining stretches to the shape of your foot for an instant custom fit.

The antibacterial agent in the lining does a great job of killing bad odors by killing the bacteria that are responsible for them.

The tread pattern is unusual. Instead of a series of lines, or a series of lugs, it has both. This makes the traction on this model something to write home about.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

I’d advise that you check the company’s sizing chart before ordering. The sizes are a bit smaller than usual, so it’s prudent to order one size bigger than usual.

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Waterproof
  • Some insulation
  • Outstanding traction

Cons

  • The sizing isn’t standard

These might not be making it to a fashion runway anytime soon, but who cares? They’ll keep your feet warm and dry.

Overall Rating

4 out of 5 Simple design to keep you high and dry.

Check Price on Amazon

MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot

I debated about including these here because they have a rubber shoe part and a fabric shank. In the end, though, I decided that they deserved a place on this list.

Key Features

  • Fabric shank
  • Rubber foot
  • Neoprene inner for waterproofing
  • Fleece lined for extra warmth
  • Thermal foam built into the footbed to insulate from ground cold
  • Easy to pull on or off
  • Stretch-fit top for the perfect fit
  • Reinforced instep and heel
  • Protection for the Achilles tendon
  • The distance between the arch and the shaft is about 15 inches

What I Like About This Product

The company set out to build their warmest boots ever, and they succeeded. The soft fleece inside gives you an extra layer of warmth and comfort.

The stretch-fit top fits snugly so that no trace of cold air is going to trickle in.

The outsoles are strong and have a great track pattern. These are designed to maximize your grip on cold, icy surfaces. The thermal foam underfoot is a nice touch for added comfort and protection against the cold.

Muck Boots have earned a reputation as being hard-wearing and highly practical. With this version, they’ve delivered in spades.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

They’re great for colder weather but are too warm in warm weather.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Comfortable
  • Very warm
  • Fit snugly
  • Strong outsoles
  • Toes are reinforced

Cons

  • Not much use outside of winter

I was tempted to give these the title of best rubber hunting boots in this rubber hunting boot review. In the end, though, they are a more specialized item, so I couldn’t follow through.

Overall Rating

4 ½ out of 5 Stay warm and keep frosty.

Check Price on Amazon

Bogs Men’s Classic High Camo Winter Snow Boot

If you want boots that are simply just to pull on and off, you won’t go wrong with this set. With a stretchy top, these enable a perfect fit.

Key Features

  • Made from rubber
  • Imported
  • Thick sole made of rubber
  • Distance from the shaft to the arch is around 12 inches
  • High-quality material
  • Waterproof
  • Good insulation
  • Inner bootie stretches for a perfect fit

What I Like About This Product

If it’s cold out, you’re going to want to pull on these boots. They’re comfortable, durable and will keep your feet dry.

They’re cut higher to ensure that you can step into a reasonable amount of water. The uppers are made of neoprene that has some stretch in it. This helps create a secure fit and prevents water spilling over the top into the booth.

The boots come in a range of colors and designs so that you can tailor your look.

The bootie on the inside has moisture wicking properties. It also helps to improve insulation in general. These will keep your feet warm even in colder temperatures. If the mercury is dropping, there’s more than enough space for thermal socks.

The antibacterial agents in the lining help to negate odor-causing bacteria.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

Breathability here could be an issue. Also, as with our previous option, order a size larger than you think you’ll need.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Good insulation
  • High-quality materials
  • Durable
  • Odor control embedded

Cons

  • No breathability
  • Smaller sized than normal

Overall, this pair comes in as a good buy option. It’s affordable, comfortable, and durable.

Overall Rating

4 out of 5

Check Price on Amazon

Bogs Men’s Bowman Waterproof Hunting Boot

Here’s another fantastic insulated boot for those of you tackling snow and ice.

Key Features

  • Lightweight
  • Rubber with some textile upper
  • Waterproof
  • Neoprene provides insulation
  • The distance from the shaft to the arch measures around 14.5 inches
  • Lining wicks moisture away
  • Built-in odor control
  • Useful carry space built in

What I Like About This Product

Just one small thing to get out of the way. The built-in carry spaces here are a great idea. When you’ve just washed your boots, it makes them a lot easier to carry.

These are made of high-quality materials. They provide good insulation. It’s not as effective as the MuckBoots option, but it’s still going to keep you warm. The insulation is provided by neoprene, and this helps keep the boot lighter.

The tread ensures that you’re not going to slip easily.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

You’ll need to wear some thick socks. These do tend to rub in the beginning and cause blisters.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Good insulation
  • Odor control
  • Comfortable
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • Can cause rubbing and blisters

Overall, these stack up pretty well against the others that we’ve reviewed. The rubbing inside is a problem easily solved by wearing socks. It’s also not an uncommon problem with rubber boots. Once they’re properly broken in, they should be fine.

Overall Rating

4 out of 5 You expect the best, don’t settle for less.

Check Price on Amazon

Kamik Men’s Hunter Boot – My Top Pick

The innovative design of these boots was what made them my top pick. Wear them with the liner for maximum warmth. Wear them without it when the weather is nice.

Key Features

  • Waterproof
  • Insulated to -40°F
  • The thermal liner can be removed for warmer weather
  • Snow collar is adjustable
  • The distance from the arch to the shaft is around 13 inches
  • Made from recycled materials

What I Like About This Product

The liner is soft and comfortable and provides a lot of warmth. What I like about these, though, is that you can take the lining out. This makes them a more versatile purchase year-round.

The boots also have an adjustable collar that allows you to get a snug fit. The boot is high enough that you’re protected even in a deeper snow drift.

The fact that they’re made using recycled materials is the icing on the cake. They’ve been carefully designed and well made. They should last you a good few seasons.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

It’s one of my pet peeves that sizing seems to differ from brand to brand. Don’t forget to check the size chart carefully and order a little larger when in doubt.

Pros

  • Durable
  • Excellent insulation
  • Comfortable
  • Adjustable collar
  • The liner can be removed during warm weather

Cons

  • Check your sizing before ordering

Overall, these are a good buy. The removable liner makes them one of the more versatile models that we’ve tried.

Overall Rating

4 ½ out of 5 Maybe if the night king wore these, he’d have been in a better mood

Check Price on Amazon

MuckBoots Wetland Boot

This is another option that is good for colder climes. The boots are rated for temperatures between -20°F to 50°F. They’re comfortable, warm, and easy to clean. What more could you possibly want?

Key Features

  • Made from rubber and neoprene
  • Waterproof
  • Good insulation
  • Neoprene inner molds to the shape of your foot
  • Stretch-fit top
  • Mesh lining to draw away sweat while allowing some air circulation
  • Outsole shrugs off mud and dirt
  • EVA in the midsole to improve comfort
  • Excellent traction
  • Toe reinforced for extra protection

What I Like About This Product

The expandable calf makes it easier to get a better fit. If you have bigger calves, check the sizing chart before ordering. With the right size, these are very comfortable.

I also like that the neoprene takes on the shape of your feet. This leaves you feeling even more comfortable with the fit.

Overall, out in the cold, these perform well. You’ll be thankful for the extra cushioning provided by the EVA midsole on a long hike.

What I Don’t Like About This Product

Order a size bigger than you’d usually wear. This is a smaller make.

Pros

  • Comfortable
  • Waterproof
  • Well-insulated
  • Great traction
  • Snug fit
  • The liner helps keep feet dry
  • Durable

Cons

  • The calf can be a little snug. If you have thicker calves, consider a bigger size.

If you’re looking for a good pair of boots that won’t let you down, these are an excellent choice.

Overall Rating

4 out of 5

Check Price on Amazon

Buying Guide

If you are a serious hunter, you’ll want to be out there as often as you can. Sometimes this means getting out there in the early hours of the morning. It might mean hunting in snowy weather or getting drenched with rain.

The point is that you need to remain as comfortable as possible to stay in the field. That’s hard to do if your feet are cold, wet, or aching. That’s why choosing your hunting boots is an essential first step.

In this section, we’ll go through what you need to consider before buying your first pair.

Budgetary Considerations

Wouldn’t it be great if we always had enough money to buy what we wanted? Unfortunately, that’s not how the world works. That’s why I suggest figuring out how much you can spend on your purchase.

You can narrow down the options and not fall in love with a pair that is way above your price range.

How Much Will You Use Them?

Have you been hunting for a while, or is it a relatively new hobby? If the bug has bitten and you know that you’re going to be out there every chance you get, then spend a bit more. You might even consider getting a second pair as a backup.

If you’re going to be using them every weekend, you need a higher quality option, a durable option that will last longer.

The second part of this section is related to specialty options. These often cost more and have more limited usefulness. A pair of waders, for example, is ideal if you’re heading off to a swampy area.

How much would you use them in the drier areas of Texas, though? Before buying any pair, think about how useful they are all around—in terms of where you normally hunt.

Are They Easy to Use?

Boots are simple by nature. You stick your foot in, lace them up, and you’re done. What I’m talking about here is how easily you’re able to put them on and take them off. If you have to fiddle with endless straps or intricate lacing, they’re not as easy to use, which means that your pricey purchase is probably going to be benched for a good few seasons.

How Much Care Do They Require?

This is one area that we don’t give too much thought to. It’s something that we need to consider, though. If you’re buying any of the rubber boots listed above, cleaning is not going to be much of an issue.

All you’ll need to do is to rinse the boots thoroughly and leave them to dry. You can then chip off any dried mud left over.

With nylon boots, you might need more than a quick rinse. You might need to scrub the dirt off. In all fairness, though, as long as you let the fabric dry out properly, dirt and grime are not going to any damage.

Leather is the most durable material, but only if you care for it properly. That means cleaning off all the dirt, getting them properly dry, and being sure to nourish the leather.

When choosing, consider how much work you want to do to clean and maintain your boots.

Durability

Durability is essential for a few reasons. Number one is that these boots are not cheap. You want to get a pair that will last you a good while. Look at the quality of the stitching and the materials that are used to construct the boot.

Also, check out who the manufacturers are. Do they have a reputation for superb products, or are there a lot of complaints about them?

Overall, leather is bound to outlast nylon if you keep it well looked after. A good pair of rubber boots will also last well. They’ll eventually start to smell a bit funky, but they have a good lifespan.

Your Hunting Grounds

Someone hunting in the snow and ice of Alaska has very different needs to someone hunting in a dry, arid region like Texas, which is different from most elk hunting environments. You need to figure out where you’ll spend most of your time.

When it comes to areas with a lot of snow and ice, you’ll need boots with excellent traction, waterproofing, and insulation.

If you’re in a drier, warmer area, breathability will be more important than insulation.

Hiding Your Scent

Some manufacturers include chemicals in the lining of the inner sole. These kill off the bacteria on your feet. This is useful if you have sweaty feet. Without the bacteria to process the sweat and create waste products, your feet won’t smell as much.

When it comes to scent masking, your choice of material on the outside is going to count more. Leather leave s a distinct smell that your prey can pick up. You’ll have to use some sort of scent masker to counteract it.

Hunters often use rubber boots instead because they don’t leave the same trail.

How High the Boot Is

This is a critical aspect to consider. Every inch of extra height means a little bit of extra weight, so you might not automatically want to go for the longest option. Let’s look at some of the options.

  • Ankle-high boots: These cover your feet and ankle. They are great for providing support, and not as restrictive when you need to move fast. They offer no protection against scratches, bites, and so on. You’ll have to stick to shallow puddles.
  • Mid-Calf Length: These are also very versatile and less restrictive. They support the ankle and the lower leg to an extent. You get more protection from the environment. You also have more leeway in terms of the amount of water you can walk in.
  • Knee Length: This is the length that a lot of hunters prefer since it offers maximum protection and support. It’s a good idea if you’ll be wading through streams. These are more restrictive, though, and holds more heat in.

Traction and Sole Support

Generally speaking, the thicker the sole, the less flexible it will be. It will last longer before wearing out, but that lack of flexibility may become something of an issue. You’re walking over uneven terrain and need your feet to be able to grip.

Some flex in the sole makes this a lot easier. At the same time, though, you also want adequate protection against sharp stones and so on.

Whether you choose a thicker or thinner sole, make sure that it has great traction. Check the tread pattern to see whether pebbles might get caught in it. Also, ensure that it is deep enough to give you excellent grip in slippery mud.

Boot Weight

Ideally, you want something as lightweight as possible. The boots might not feel that heavy at home. How good will they feel when you’ve been chasing down prey for a few hours wearing your full kit?

Waterproofing

I’d be a little concerned if you manage to find a rubber boot that isn’t waterproof, but some boots do have fabric portions higher on the boot. In this case, whether this area is also waterproof is an important consideration.

Insulation

I don’t feel that insulation is as important as waterproofing. A big part of keeping your feet warm is keeping them dry. So, if you have to choose between the two, stick to the waterproofing. You can always wear thermal socks if necessary.

That said, insulation can make you feel a lot more comfortable when the temperatures are freezing. On the other hand, it can also make your feet sweat bullets when it’s hot out.

My best advice is to be guided by the conditions that you’ll typically hunt under. If it’s going to be icy, get insulated boots. If it’s usually nice and warm out, then insulation might not be necessary.

Get the Right Fit

I’ve left this for last because it’s something so many of us forget about. You check all the features about a boot, and then just order your standard size. You need to be more careful. Not all boots are standard sizes.

The sizes fluctuate depending on the brand, and sometimes even within the brand as well.

You’ll need to be able to comfortably get in and out of the boots with socks on. If you’re going to be wearing a few pairs of socks, this becomes even more important.

The right fit will feel relatively comfortable straight off the bat. You’ll have to break them in, of course, but a pair of boots that’s wildly uncomfortable at this stage is not going to get much better.

You should have some room for your toes and ensure that no areas are pinching.

If possible, go to a store to try on some different makes so that you know which fit better. If you’re buying online, check the company’s sizing chart, and whether other buyers have had issues.

 

Final Thoughts

All the boots that I reviewed here are winners, but the Kamik stands out head and shoulders above the rest. Others in the group provided great insulation as well, but the versatility of the Kamik makes it really special.

The best rubber hunting boots in 2019 are made by those companies who take their client needs to heart. While MuckBoots and Bogs have both made great strides in this area, it’s Kamik that wins the race in this rubber hunting boot review.

Leave a Reply