Pancake Holsters - Review Of The Top Products [Updated 2020 ]

Last Updated: February 12, 2020 by Aiden Williams

Finding the best pancake holsters might seem difficult in today’s crowded market, but it’s not as hard as it seems if you know what to look for. This type of holsters has been used for a long time, and people still use it because it’s a comfortable outside the waistband solution for both open and concealed carry.

In the following article, we take a look at the top 10 pancake holsters currently available on the market and we examine the pros and cons of using each model.

4.8 Customer Rating
Relentless Tactical Leather Pancake Holster
Made : Genuine cowhide leather
Design : 3-slot pancake design
Fits : Most 1911-style pistols
Hand Orientation : Left & Right

4.7 Customer Rating
OutBags Side Carry Pancake Holster
Made : Hand dyed full grain leather
Design : Compact design
Fits : S&W Shield 9mm, .40S&W
Hand Orientation : Left & Right

4.1 Customer Rating
Barsony Ambidextrous Pancake Holster
Made : Nylon
Design : 6 position
Fits : Most full-sized 9 mm and .45 pistols
Hand Orientation : Left & Right

4.1 Customer Rating
TEGE Polymer Belt Holster
Made : Tough polymer
Design : Auto lock Design
Fits : Most popular Glock models and similarly-styled handguns
Hand Orientation : Right

4.4 Customer Rating
Gould & Goodrich Three Slot Holster
Made : Genuine leather
Design : Three Slot Design
Fits : a lot of gun models, including the Glock 19 and similarly-sized units
Hand Orientation : Right

Table of Contents

Pancake Holsters (The Top List)
Best Pancake Holsters Comparison Chart
Wrap Up

Pancake Holsters (The Top List)

1. Relentless Tactical Leather Pancake Holster

We start this list by reviewing one of the most popular pancake holsters available on the market. The Relentless Tactical holster is made out of genuine cowhide leather and it has a 3-slot pancake design that will allow you to carry your pistol just as you like it. Thanks to the holster’s versatility, you can wear it on your strong side, behind the hip, or in a cross-draw position.

We were impressed by the holster’s carry capacity. This model is large enough to accommodate full-sized handguns, and you can fit most 1911-style pistols in it without any problems, no matter how long their barrel is. This is a good holster for the Glock 19, and it will fit other similarly-sized models. The only difference between holding a long-barreled and a short-barreled pistol is that the first one will ride lower than the second.

Pro

High-Quality Construction – This holster is made out of genuine leather, and it has a high-quality construction.

Con

Snug Fit – The holster will fit your 1911 handgun snugly at first, but the leather will loosen up over time.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

2. OutBags Side Carry Pancake Holster

The OutBags side carry pancake holster is made out of hand dyed full grain leather. The leather used for the holster’s construction has been cured and hardened, so it will maintain its custom shape no matter how often you use it. This holster was specially designed to hold compact and subcompact handguns, and it will fit a lot of different models.

One of the things we appreciated about this model was that it’s easy to conceal. Thanks to its compact design, the holster is easy to hide underneath a shirt or a jacket when you side carry. Another good thing about this model is that it will fit your pistol nicely and it will keep it from moving.

Pro

Comfortable – Thanks to its compact design, the holster will be comfortable to carry for a long time.

Con

Needs Some Breaking In – The holster’s leather is somewhat stiff at first, so you will have to break it in a little if you want to draw quickly

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

3. Barsony Ambidextrous Pancake Holster

The Barsony ambidextrous pancake holster is a good model that comes at a decent price. Unlike the pancake holster’s we reviewed so far, this model is made out of nylon, not leather. One of the advantages of using a nylon holster instead of a leather one is that it’s lighter. This will allow you to wear the holster for an entire day without feeling any discomfort. Nylon holsters are also more resilient to the elements.

As far as this model’s carry capacity is concerned, the holster will fit most full-sized 9 mm and .45 pistols. The holster’s loops are 1 ¾” wide, and they will fit on most CCW belts.

Pro

Low Profile – This holster has a low profile, so it shouldn’t be difficult to conceal even in the warm season

Con

Stiff Thumb Break – This model uses a thumb break to secure your pistol. Unfortunately, the thumb break is stiff and it will slow down your draw time.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

4. TEGE Polymer Belt Holster

The TEGE holster is made out of a tough polymer that will withstand anything you put it through. This model is specially designed to fit the most popular Glock models and similarly-styled handguns. Unfortunately, the holster will not accommodate the Glock 19 Gen 5, but it will hold the Gen 4 comfortably.

One of the things we liked about this model is that it comes with an auto-lock system that ensures your gun won’t move or wobble when it’s holstered. Drawing the gun is very comfortable, and you can press the release button using a single finger, which means you will also be able to draw your pistol quickly.

Pro

Adjustable Paddle Cant – This holster comes with an adjustable paddle cant, so you can incline your pistol by up to 30 degrees.

Con

Difficult To Conceal – This holster can stand out underneath your clothes, so it’s difficult to conceal.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

5. Gould & Goodrich Three Slot Holster

Another public favorite, the Gould & Goodrich pancake holster has an amazing design that will make carrying your handgun a comfortable experience, even if you carry it for long periods of time.

We were impressed by this holster’s construction. The leather has a great quality, but it’s not too thick, so it won’t be heavy. The stitching is nice and precise, and the holster comes with three slots, so you can either carry it with a forward cant or a high ride. The holster’s slots are wide, so it would be better if you would wear it with tactical pants instead of regular jeans or slacks.

The holster will fit a lot of gun models, including the Glock 19 and similarly-sized units.

Pro

Slim Design – This model has a slim design, so it’s rather easy to conceal underneath clothing

Con

Needs Time To Loosen – Even though the holster’s leather is not too thick, you will have to have patience with it to loosen up.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

4.5 Customer Rating
Bulldog Cases Black Leather Holster
Made : High-quality leather
Design : Unique generous design
Fits : All Glocks frames, Ruger P85, M&P40, XD etc.
Hand Orientation : Right

4.1 Customer Rating
Barsony Leather Pancake Holster
Made : Genuine cowhide
Design : Slim design
Fits : 380 and Small 9mm 40 45
Hand Orientation : Left & Right

4.3 Customer Rating
Safariland 328 Pancake Holster
Made : High Quality Leather
Design : Top draw design
Fits : Glocks 17, 22, 31, and similarly-sized
Hand Orientation : Right

4.8 Customer Rating
Huston Gun Holsters Pancake Tactical Holster
Made : Ecological leather
Design : multiple CCW Positions Design
Fits : Glock 19 23 32 26 27 33 30 | M&P Shield, XDs, Taurus PT111
Hand Orientation : Right

4.0 Customer Rating
DeSantis Pro Stealth Pancake Holster
Made : Black nylon
Design : powder-coated spring Design
Fits : Diamondback DB380/KAHR P380/Keltec P3AT/Ruger LCP/Sig P238/S and W Bodyguard .380
Hand Orientation : Left & Right

6. Bulldog Cases Black Leather Holster

The Bulldog Cases pancake holster is a great budget choice for those who are looking for a leather holster but don’t want to break the bank to buy one. Despite its low price, this model is made out of high-quality leather that’s been tanned by hand.

One of the things we liked about this model is that it has a generous design. This will make the holster wide enough to accommodate large frame autos, including all the auto Glocks, the M&P 40, and similarly-sized models.

The holster comes with only two slots, so you won’t be able to change the pistol’s inclination. Thus, the holster is only suitable for those who like to carry their handguns in the high ride CCW position.

Pro

Fits Great – This model will fit your full-sized auto handgun so well, you might think it’s tailor-fitted instead of a generic model

Con

Doesn’t Cover The Trigger – This holster will fit most full-sized autos, but it might not cover the trigger of some models. This might be problematic for some people

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

7. Barsony Leather Pancake Holster

The Barsony leather pancake holster is a small and slim model that will hold most compact handguns. This holster is made out of genuine cowhide, and its slim design will keep the pistol close to your body, allowing you to conceal it with ease, even if you wear the holster during the warm season.

We liked that this holster’s leather has a pleasant feel to it and that it will maintain its form after you shape it for your gun. The holster’s stitching has a high-quality, and it will help the holster keep your pistol secure as you move.

Pro

Keeps Shape Well – The holster will maintain its shape well, securing your pistol and preventing it from moving

Con

Needs Shaping – You will need to shape the holster to fit your gun properly. To do this, you will need to put it into boiling water and dry it out

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

8. Safariland 328 Pancake Holster

The Safariland pancake holster is a good model that comes with three slots, allowing you to choose the cant position you’re most comfortable with. Depending on your preference, you can choose between the high rise and the forward cant CCW position.

One of the things we liked about this model is that it will keep your pistol firmly in place. The holster comes with a thumb break that will keep your handgun from wobbling as you move. However, the thumb strap is easy to remove using a single finger, so you will still be able to draw the pistol quickly when you have to.

The holster will fit the Glocks 17, 22, 31, and similarly-sized models.

Pro

Suede Lining – The holster comes with a suede lining that will protect your handgun from scratches

Con

Narrow Slots – The holster should fit a 1 ¾ belt, but its slots might need some loosening up to do so.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

9. Huston Gun Holsters Pancake Tactical Holster

The Huston Gun Holders is a good pancake holster that comes at a decent price. This model is made out of ecological leather that’s nice to the touch and it has a suede interior that will protect your handgun from scratches. The eco leather is resilient to the elements and it’s even waterproof, so it should last for a long time.

We liked that this model’s design allows you to choose between multiple CCW positions to carry your handgun. The holster can be used with good results both as an IWB and OWB model, and thanks to its slim design you will be able to conceal it with relative ease. This unit is large enough to accommodate most popular Glocks and other similarly-sized handguns.

Pro

Comfortable – This holster is very comfortable to wear, so you can carry your handgun for a whole day without experiencing any discomfort

Con

Leather Back – The holster has a leather back, so it can stick to your skin in the warm season

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

10. DeSantis Pro Stealth Pancake Holster

The DeSantis Pro Stealth is a small and comfortable pancake holster that comes at a decent price. This model is made out of black nylon and its back is padded for a more comfortable carry. The holster comes with a powder-coated spring that will fit any 1 ¾” leather or tactical belt. The clip can be removed and reinstalled on the other side of the holster, making this model suitable for an ambidextrous carry.

The holster’s ballistic nylon has a high quality, and its edges won’t bite into your skin. The holster is large enough to accommodate most compact handguns without adding noticeable bulk to your waistline

Pro

Spare Mag – The holster can accommodate an extra magazine if you ever need one.

Con

Thumb Strap Is Optional – This holster can be fitted with a thumb strap, but only if you pay extra for it.

Check The Latest Price on Amazon!

Best Pancake Holsters Comparison Chart

PRODUCT	MADE	DESIGN	FITS	HAND ORIENTATION
Relentless Tactical Leather Pancake Holster	Genuine cowhide leather	3-slot design	Most 1911-style pistols	Left & Right
OutBags Side Carry Pancake Holster	Hand dyed full grain leather	Compact design	S&W Shield 9mm, .40S&W	Left & Right
Barsony Ambidextrous Pancake Holster	Nylon	6 position	Most full-sized 9 mm and .45 pistols	Left & Right
TEGE Polymer Belt Holster	Tough polymer	Auto lock Design	Most popular Glock models and similarly-styled handguns	Right
Gould & Goodrich Three Slot Holster	Genuine leather	Three Slot Design	a lot of gun models, including the Glock 19 and similarly-sized units	Right
Bulldog Cases Black Leather Holster	High-quality leather	Unique generous design	All Glocks frames, Ruger P85, M&P40, XD etc.	Right
Barsony Leather Pancake Holster	Genuine cowhide	Slim design	380 and Small 9mm 40 45	Left & Right
Safariland 328 Pancake Holster	High Quality Leather	Top draw design	Glocks 17, 22, 31, and similarly-sized	Right
Huston Gun Holsters Pancake Tactical Holster	Ecological leather	Multiple CCW Positions Design	Glock 19 23 32 26 27 33 30 \| M&P Shield, XDs, Taurus PT111	Right
DeSantis Pro Stealth Pancake Holster	Black nylon	Powder-coated spring Design	Diamondback DB380/KAHR P380/Keltec P3AT/Ruger LCP/Sig P238/S and W Bodyguard .380	Left & Right

Wrap Up

As you could see, finding the best pancake holsters is not really that difficult if you know what to look for as an alternative concealed carry holster. The first thing you should make sure of is that the holster is large enough to accommodate your handgun. Moreover, you should make sure the holster is not too large for your handgun, otherwise, you might be surprised to discover that your pistol wobbles as you move. Last but not least, you should make sure the holster can be worn as you like it to. Everyone has a favorite carry position, but not every holster can provide all of them.